M 3.3 Justice!
ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE
In the EPA's 2007 definition of environmental justice, there is a clause stating, "It will be achieved when everyone enjoys the same degree of protection from environmental and health hazards and equal access to the decision-making process...".
When everyone enjoys the same degree of protection? How is that supposed to be accomplished? Will there be a 100% mandatory participation survey given to 100% of the American populace? Wouldn't there be a fair assumption that all people deserve justice, general welfare, and and domestic tranquility as per the US Constitution? To me, this specific line in the EPA's definition of justice is a big gray area where someone may have subconsciously placed blame on the people based on an assumption that not everyone enjoys the same degree of protection.
The National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences and the Minority Worker Training Program seem to be excellent resources for helping affected and exposed people take initiative to work in the field in hopes to change the controversies. The best knowledge of an environment should realistically come from those who reside in it, so providing funding to allow them to work in the field is a great step in the right direction.
In some aspects, I feel that environmental justice also depends on where communities begin to build. If a small town starts isolated in the middle of a desert with the hopes of sustaining, then it would be up to that community's leader to determine what environmental measures are just for that community. Now if a chemical plant wants to build a toxic landfill nearby, that should be considered unfair and controlled by the EPA. Why toxic landfills can't be a certain amount of miles away from any type of town beats me. There's a landfill just on the outskirts of Vacaville, CA where there are hundreds of square miles of fields between there and the next town. Sure, there are agricultural farms around as well, which poses a risk to the farms and food supply. It's a catch-22 regardless in that case.
In the EPA's 2007 definition of environmental justice, there is a clause stating, "It will be achieved when everyone enjoys the same degree of protection from environmental and health hazards and equal access to the decision-making process...".
When everyone enjoys the same degree of protection? How is that supposed to be accomplished? Will there be a 100% mandatory participation survey given to 100% of the American populace? Wouldn't there be a fair assumption that all people deserve justice, general welfare, and and domestic tranquility as per the US Constitution? To me, this specific line in the EPA's definition of justice is a big gray area where someone may have subconsciously placed blame on the people based on an assumption that not everyone enjoys the same degree of protection.
The National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences and the Minority Worker Training Program seem to be excellent resources for helping affected and exposed people take initiative to work in the field in hopes to change the controversies. The best knowledge of an environment should realistically come from those who reside in it, so providing funding to allow them to work in the field is a great step in the right direction.
In some aspects, I feel that environmental justice also depends on where communities begin to build. If a small town starts isolated in the middle of a desert with the hopes of sustaining, then it would be up to that community's leader to determine what environmental measures are just for that community. Now if a chemical plant wants to build a toxic landfill nearby, that should be considered unfair and controlled by the EPA. Why toxic landfills can't be a certain amount of miles away from any type of town beats me. There's a landfill just on the outskirts of Vacaville, CA where there are hundreds of square miles of fields between there and the next town. Sure, there are agricultural farms around as well, which poses a risk to the farms and food supply. It's a catch-22 regardless in that case.
The concept of the "same degree of protection" is also concerning to me because we know populations have different starting points. I understand that the same policies could be implemented in every neighborhood, county, and state, but how are we supposed to make sure everyone is on a level playing field when the damage has already been done to our poorest populations? Of course we must look to the future, but this definitely tugs at the equity vs. equality issue for me.
ReplyDeleteThanks for pointing out the definition. It's definitely an outdated language considering that we've moved away from using equal/equality to equity.
ReplyDeleteI agree that those who reside in the neighborhood know what is needed for their community. It would be great to see local environment changes happen.